Eating Disorder Support Forum banner
  • Important - Please Read This website may include conversations, media, and content around topics relating to eating disorders, trauma, addiction, and mental health. Please be aware that this content may be upsetting, difficult, or triggering for some. EDSF is intended as a place of safety. If you or someone you know is struggling with an eating disorder, Feast-ED.org is a resource that lists the organizations set up to help.

A friendly reminder regarding tips seeking

571K views 1K replies 857 participants last post by  Pinkiesup  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
(Let's talk strictly anorexia and bulimia for a moment.)

To those of you who are here seeking diet tips: Many members on this site have an eating disorder. We didn't sit down and decide that we'd like to lose weight. None of us will recommend to you doing the things that we've done. We understand what it's like to be stuck at a higher weight, hating yourself, but we also want you to understand, you're not going to love yourself or your body any more once you lose weight this way.

It is your body and there's nothing we can do to really stop you from doing any of this--from reading the forums, from taking tips--and we're not going to try. If you are going to do this, we'd like you to do it as safely as possible, and we can help you with that. We just want you to understand the risks of what you're doing, and to consider the fact that you will be harming your body, and that this could kill you.

Also, please think about this: diets are not all about losing weight quickly. It's about losing it and keeping it off. You should lose weight the healthy way and it is possible, period. There are no excuses, like, "oh, I've tried everything, nothing works!"--if you eat right and exercise, you WILL see results, end of story. We can't do that. If I could choose to start all over at 160 and lose weight the right way, I would in an instant. I've lost 35lbs since relapse and I still hate my body. I will always hate it, because I am sick. You could die doing this. We want you to understand the risks.

This community is, however, accepting of all of its members. You will not be treated any differently if you have an ED than if you don't have an ED. You will become part of the family here, no matter what. We will encourage you to seek help and we will support you through whatever mess you're in, but we do not encourage people to starve themselves. You will receive information on weight loss and nutrition from the experts, but you will not be told to starve yourself.

To the long-standing members: This site is all-inclusive. We should be accepting of everyone who comes here, even those looking for a "quick way to lose weight". We need to be supportive-- people come here for support, and to feel less alone. By telling someone without an ED who comes here to find diet tips to "leave" and that they are "stupid" or "not welcome here", you're doing far more harm than good.

We should explain these things to them. We've all become very knowledgeable about weight loss, calories, exercise, and things of this nature; they know this. If they ask us for tips, they're obviously desperate for some sort of help, so talk to them. We need to tell them what works and what will keep them healthy. Some of us know these things better than our doctors know them.

I don't want these dieters to develop develop an eating disorder any more than you do-- so show them how horrible this is for them. Warn them of the dangers. If they still want to proceed, there are obviously some deeper issues. You can encourage them to get help all you want, but ultimately, it's up to them what they do with their bodies.

I would not wish this disorder on my worst enemy. This is hell on earth.

You cannot choose to have an eating disorder, but you may develop one here. It is very triggering. You will become fascinated by food and overjoyed at your weight loss.

You may lose weight quickly through starving yourself, but that progress will be gone the moment you begin eating properly again.

This is not a diet. This is not a lifestyle. Should you choose to make this mental illness your diet or your lifestyle, you will be forever ruining your body, hurting those around you, and ultimately, killing yourself.

Once you start counting calories, you will never stop.

None of us want this for you. We want you to be happy, healthy, and able to love yourselves.

Please, be safe.
 
#3 ·
#4 ·
Thank you Emily.
Would you mind being a sort of mentor for me? I don't know if it's too much to ask but you seem like the type of help and support I am looking for. I have friends who are naturally so thin and get all the attention and I feel like I've sort of given up on myself and let my self get to a point where I am desperate to do whatever I can to change. I'm not obese just about 10-15 pounds or so over weight, I know I'll never be as thin as them but in comparison I honestly feel like I am huge. Plus I'm shorter. I know comparing myself is bad and I shouldn't do it but I can't help it when I plainly see people treating us differently based on how we look. I am not happy with my body and it really deeply upsets me.

If you can't and know of any other options for me I'd be greatful to hear that too.
 
#5 · (Edited by Moderator)
Thank you Emily.
Would you mind being a sort of mentor for me? I don't know if it's too much to ask but you seem like the type of help and support I am looking for. I have friends who are naturally so thin and get all the attention and I feel like I've sort of given up on myself and let my self get to a point where I am desperate to do whatever I can to change. I'm not obese just about 10-15 pounds or so over weight, I know I'll never be as thin as them but in comparison I honestly feel like I am huge. Plus I'm shorter. I know comparing myself is bad and I shouldn't do it but I can't help it when I plainly see people treating us differently based on how we look. I am not happy with my body and it really deeply upsets me.

If you can't and know of any other options for me I'd be greatful to hear that too.
If you'd like to change your body, you're very welcome to seek support here. We will help you, but I do encourage you to do things right the first time so that you can still love yourself and so that you can keep off any weight you feel like loosing.

A big problem for girls (and some guys), especially in this day and age, is body image. Sweetheart, you've got to realize that you are not defined by the way you look. You are so much more than that. Maybe you're an athlete or you like to read at home by the window while it's raining. Maybe you're smart, or maybe you're artistic, or maybe you have a job that really makes a difference in people's lives. Maybe you like cats, maybe you like dogs. Maybe you hate animals, who knows? Maybe you're great at something that all of your friends are jealous of you for. Maybe you're a writer or you play video games, or you like the taste of chocolate cake more than anything else. Maybe your handwriting is horrible or you always give away the punchline of a joke and you can never tell stories just right-- but that's all okay.

You are yourself and that's all that matters. And if someone is going to treat you differently or think less of you because you're not at a certain weight or your nose is too big or your eyes are a little droopy or your hands aren't the right size or you don't have your belly button pierced or you have your ears stretched so big you can flip your lobes up over your head or because you have tattoos all over or your boobs are small or your butt is flat-- or even because you're too skinny or your nose is too small or your eyes are too wide or anything-- if anyone is going to base their opinion of you off of your appearance, they do not deserve to be in your life.

If you want to lose weight, you should be losing it for yourself. You should lose it because you want to. You should lose it because it will make you more confident about yourself. You should lose it because you want to look a certain way, because you deserve to look however you want to look.

But please, please don't lose weight so that you can compare yourself to others. You deserve to love your body. You deserve to be confident in that crop top or those tight jeans that make your butt look good. You deserve to do all of these things that I just can't do.

We'll support you while you're here and I can tell you everything I know about weight loss, but please don't go about this the wrong way, and please don't do it for the wrong reasons. You deserve to love yourself.
 
#7 ·
Thanks again. :') that helps. There is so much more that I can say but I'd rather not go back and forth on something so public. But your words did touch me and are appreciated.
Any time, love. You're welcome to message me if you'd like.
 
#9 ·
Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU for making this post!! I feel like we can all use a reminder that this is an all-inclusive community. We're here to help each other, no matter what kinda things we may be going through!

So much love <3
 
#12 ·
Emily..you are amazing! your posts touched me so deeply.beautiful!
 
#13 ·
Clarissa, I'm hoping this helps at least one person <3

Thank you Angelica!
 
#15 ·
Nice post! Agree with it 100%! Hopefully every new member will see this in the future!

But I thought my way around the whole "once you start restricting yourself, you can't stop or you'll gain weight". Well, of course, once I stop, I'll gain weight, but I decided to make my UGW 100 for a reason. You see, my real goal weight is 115 but I'm shooting lower, so that once I gain the weight, it will still be less than 120. (Of course, I'll still exercise and stuff so that I won't gain it all back...and I'll take it slow too.)

Then from there, I shall swear to myself to NEVER allow my body weight to be above 120!

That's pretty much how I'm gonna go about this.
 
#16 ·
Nice post! Agree with it 100%! Hopefully every new member will see this in the future!

But I thought my way around the whole "once you start restricting yourself, you can't stop or you'll gain weight". Well, of course, once I stop, I'll gain weight, but I decided to make my UGW 100 for a reason. You see, my real goal weight is 115 but I'm shooting lower, so that once I gain the weight, it will still be less than 120. (Of course, I'll still exercise and stuff so that I won't gain it all back...and I'll take it slow too.)

Then from there, I shall swear to myself to NEVER allow my body weight to be above 120!

That's pretty much how I'm gonna go about this.
The thing is, you can very easily lose this weight the healthy way, without harming your body. Your metabolism will slow down, your stomach will shrink, and you won't be able to eat normally ever again. What you're going to end up doing is hitting 100, then (if you're not irreparably mentally or physically damaged at the end of all this) you'll shoot back up, higher than you've ever been. I know, because this happened to me in recovery. I gained 66lbs. I had never been that big, ever.

This "diet" is depriving your body of nutrients that it needs to function properly. You are starving yourself. We have to do this because we are mentally ill, but you do not. You can quit whenever you want to. And we envy you for that, and we all want you to stop. We all want you to turn this around before you become an empty shell of a girl, only bones, only skin. Your hair will fall out and your nails will chip and you'll break out and you'll grow tiny hairs all over your body to stay warm. This kills more people than any other mental disorder, and the "starvation diet" that you're on is dangerous.

Please stop while you can... we all wish that we could. We all wish this was just a diet, just a way to lose weight. We all wish we could have that slice of cake or that piece of pizza without hating ourselves and hurting ourselves and feeling guilty, over one item of food.

We don't want this for you, love. We want you to be happy and healthy and have a long, long life, loving yourself and not defining your worth based solely on your weight. We don't want you to be like us...
 
#23 ·
The thing is, you can very easily lose this weight the healthy way, without harming your body. Your metabolism will slow down, your stomach will shrink, and you won't be able to eat normally ever again. What you're going to end up doing is hitting 100, then (if you're not irreparably mentally or physically damaged at the end of all this) you'll shoot back up, higher than you've ever been. I know, because this happened to me in recovery. I gained 66lbs. I had never been that big, ever.

This "diet" is depriving your body of nutrients that it needs to function properly. You are starving yourself. We have to do this because we are mentally ill, but you do not. You can quit whenever you want to. And we envy you for that, and we all want you to stop. We all want you to turn this around before you become an empty shell of a girl, only bones, only skin. Your hair will fall out and your nails will chip and you'll break out and you'll grow tiny hairs all over your body to stay warm. This kills more people than any other mental disorder, and the "starvation diet" that you're on is dangerous.

Please stop while you can... we all wish that we could. We all wish this was just a diet, just a way to lose weight. We all wish we could have that slice of cake or that piece of pizza without hating ourselves and hurting ourselves and feeling guilty, over one item of food.

We don't want this for you, love. We want you to be happy and healthy and have a long, long life, loving yourself and not defining your worth based solely on your weight. We don't want you to be like us...
Thanks for your concern...but I'm not anorexic really. I have anorexic tendencies though. Like when I eat a lot or eat something fattening I feel guilty, I have to weigh myself naked and drink TONS of water! I still eat half my dinner and usually eat fruit for lunch...so I'm not "starving" myself to the extent those with ED's are...it's more like restricting.

I am well aware of how dangerous it is but I seriously NEED something to focus on other than the stress of my senior year and so that I can find ONE THING that I like about myself! I seriously despise myself, my appearance, my personality, everything...so if I'm thin, there is one thing I can say I like!

And though I have tendencies, I don't want this disorder, nor do I want to be a skeleton. (No offense). All I want is to feel somewhat happy with myself and everytime I lose weight, I feel accomplished. I can't stop now or else I'll never lose weight. Believe me, I've tried eating normally and exercising and it NEVER worked...only the times when I would do this, but in the past I would quit because I lost motivation...this website gives me it.

And I'm planning on stopping once I reach 100...but slowly. When you were recovery, I bet you had to eat a lot/ ate a lot right? I'm gonna try to slowly work my metabolism back up and continue until I'm in my proper eating habits. And if I happen to go over 120, I'll deprive myself again.

If I stop now, I'll never forgive myself. I'll fall deeper into self-loathing. Sorry but I refuse to stop until I reach my goal.
 
#24 ·
This is refreshing. but i think its important to remember that if your on a site called MyProAna, then you're pretty much already there. the only people who seek something like that are really desperate people already obsessed with weight. i know i was obsessed, restricting, binging, and counting calories YEARS before i had any idea i could attribute it to an eating disorder. because society led me to believe a person with an ED was someonr who completely deprived themselves of ALL nutrition 24 hours a day 7 days a week, until they had a heart attack and died. so i had no clue binging was an ED, or restricting or any of it. so yes we need to be all inclusive becauae if someone seeks myproana for any reason, wether its losing weight fast, they have.ana or mia, they're BED, they're most likely already desperately seeking some type of reprieve and its our job to be there. when my issues started getting bad, nothing.like this forum existed. this is an AMAZING site.
 
#25 ·
This is refreshing. but i think its important to remember that if your on a site called MyProAna, then you're pretty much already there. the only people who seek something like that are really desperate people already obsessed with weight. i know i was obsessed, restricting, binging, and counting calories YEARS before i had any idea i could attribute it to an eating disorder. because society led me to believe a person with an ED was someonr who completely deprived themselves of ALL nutrition 24 hours a day 7 days a week, until they had a heart attack and died. so i had no clue binging was an ED, or restricting or any of it. so yes we need to be all inclusive becauae if someone seeks myproana for any reason, wether its losing weight fast, they have.ana or mia, they're BED, they're most likely already desperately seeking some type of reprieve and its our job to be there. when my issues started getting bad, nothing.like this forum existed. this is an AMAZING site.
I agree with most of what you say...

But I don't have ana or mia...but more tendencies of it. So I don't think everyone on here has a full-blown eating disorder.
 
#26 ·
So well written and such a reflection of a concerned and loving heart. You are an angel Emily.